Chinese researchers have found further evidence that plants emit significant quantities of methane - a potent greenhouse gas. But the latest findings also show that methane emissions depend not just on the species of plant, but the conditions in which they are growing.
Frank Keppler, from the Max Planck Institute for Nuclear Physics, Heidelberg, Germany, first claimed in January 2006 that the world's plants, previously seen as a greenhouse gas sink thanks to their CO2 uptake, actually emit millions of tons of methane. As a greenhouse gas, methane is 20 times more potent than CO2.
While a contentious finding, subsequent studies have confirmed that plants could emit the greenhouse gas - but that emissions are species-dependent. In November 2007, Zhi-Ping Wang of the Chinese Academy of Science, Beijing, and colleagues revealed the methane emissions of 44 species of plants from the temperate grasslands of Inner Mongolia. While none of the 35 herbaceous species tested seemed to produce methane, seven out of nine shrub species did emit the gas.
However, the latest study, by Xingliang Xu of the Chinese Academy of Science in Xining and coworkers, apparently contradicts that finding. Studying an area of Tibetan alpine meadow, Xu found that shrub species took in methane from the atmosphere, while two species of herbaceous grass were emitters of the gas, contributing significantly to the regional methane levels.
But Keppler says he disagrees that the studies are contradictory, and points to the different natural environments in which the plants were growing. 'This just shows how complex living plant systems are,' Keppler told Chemistry World. 'We now know that, depending on the plant species, but also on environmental conditions and stress factors, you can get different rates of emission.'
Keppler is currently examining the mechanism by which plants might be producing methane - and recently used isotope studies to show that plant pectin, which is an important component of all land plant species, can release methane when exposed to heat or UV light. 'I think we now really need to investigate the mechanism by which living plants emit methane, so we can tell more about why plants are producing it,' he says.